October's softer-than-expected price data has split Canada's leading economists over the December 9 decision, and this report sets out the numbers, the market reaction and the case each side is making.
A second consecutive Bank of Canada rate hike on December 9 is now a coin flip, according to financial markets, after Statistics Canada reported on Monday, November 16, that annual inflation held at 3.1% in October. The figure came in a touch cooler than forecasters expected. That has opened a sharp divide among Canada’s economists over whether the central bank should tighten again or pause before the year ends.
Energy did most of the work in keeping headline inflation elevated, as crude oil prices stayed firm compared with a year earlier. Strip energy out, however, and prices rose just 2% over the year, down from 2.1% in September. That is squarely on the Bank’s 2% target.
October CPI: A 3.1% Headline Driven by Oil, 2% Underneath
Analysts surveyed by Reuters had expected the annual consumer price index to tick up to 3.2% and had pencilled in a 0.3% monthly gain. Instead, prices rose 0.2% from September, and the annual pace did not move.
Capital Economics noted that the seasonally adjusted monthly increase was half what it had forecast. The main reason was a muted 0.1% rise in prices excluding food and energy. Some categories ran warmer:
- Clothing and footwear: up 0.4% on the month.
- Health and personal care: also up 0.4%.
- Shelter: up 0.3%, firmer than its average so far this year.
- Softer categories: recreation, education and reading, household operations, furnishings and equipment, and alcoholic beverages each rose only 0.1%.
The Bank’s preferred core gauges, CPI-trim and CPI-median, rose an average of 0.20% on the month. That was the smallest combined gain in four months and only slightly above the 0.17% monthly pace consistent with the 2% target. Their three-month annualized average eased to 2.7%, and their annual average slipped to 1.9%.
| Indicator | October 2026 | Comparison |
|---|---|---|
| Headline CPI, year over year | 3.1% | 3.1% in September; 3.2% expected |
| Headline CPI, month over month | 0.2% | 0.3% expected |
| CPI excluding energy, year over year | 2.0% | 2.1% in September |
| CPI-trim and CPI-median, average annual rate | 1.9% | Edged lower |
| CPIX, year over year | 2.0% | 2.2% in September; 2.3% in August |
| Bank of Canada policy rate | 2.50% | Raised 25 basis points on Oct. 28 |
How the Loonie, Two-Year Yields and Swaps Markets Reacted
Markets read the report as mildly dovish. The Canadian dollar slipped about a tenth of a U.S. cent after the 8:30 a.m. ET release, to 69.89 cents US. The two-year Government of Canada bond yield, which tracks expectations for central bank policy closely, fell about 4 basis points to 3.317%.
Rate expectations barely moved. Overnight index swaps, as reported via Bloomberg data, put the odds of a December 9 hike at roughly 50-50. They implied an overnight rate of about 2.636% after that meeting, close to the previous week’s level.
Further out, traders are fully pricing a quarter-point increase by the Bank’s January 27, 2027, meeting. They also expect three quarter-point moves by October 2027. Several economists argued after the release that those bets are too aggressive.
Why the October Bank of Canada Rate Hike Set Up This Debate
The Bank lifted its policy rate to 2.5% on October 28. It was the first increase since 2023, and the Bank framed it as a move to stay ahead of an oil-price shock rather than a response to inflation already spreading through the economy.
That framing is central to Monday’s arguments. In its October Monetary Policy Report, the Bank projected headline inflation of 3.4% for the fourth quarter. October’s 3.1% reading is running below that path. Charles St-Arnaud, chief economist at Servus credit union, said the Bank had treated broader price pressure as a question of when, not whether. In his view, a December move will hinge more on the Bank’s forecast than on current data.

The question for policy-makers is whether higher energy costs are feeding into the prices of other goods and services. On Monday’s evidence, most economists said that pass-through has not shown up yet.
The Case for Holding at 2.5% in December
A broad group of forecasters said the report gives the Bank room to wait.
- Capital Economics (Stephen Brown): There is little sign that the energy surge is reaching core inflation. Brown expects the Bank to pause in December and treat further moves as “insurance hikes,” resuming increases in the new year.
- CIBC (Andrew Grantham): Headline inflation is above the top of the Bank’s 1% to 3% target band but well below the 3.4% fourth-quarter forecast, and it will likely ease further in November as gasoline prices fall. CIBC is calling for a hold.
- TD (Leslie Preston): Signs of hotter prices were “fairly lukewarm.” TD expects core inflation to climb into the 2.5% to 3% range in coming months but does not think a soft economy warrants more tightening this year.
- Citi (Veronica Clark): Food prices and rents were weaker than Citi expected. Clark noted the Bank’s own guidance that it will “proceed carefully” with further hikes, and she expects no change in December.
- RSM Canada (Tu Nguyen): Flat headline and core readings, a soft job market and lower oil prices in November point to a hold at 2.5%.
- CPA Canada (David-Alexandre Brassard): Core inflation fell below 2%, so the data does not signal broader pressure. Having already moved once, the Bank can wait and watch.
David Rosenberg, founder of Rosenberg Research, made the most pointed version of the argument. It may be time, he said, for the Bank to go back to the drawing board and focus on slack in the economy, pointing to three straight months of net job losses and slowing wage growth. The CPIX measure, which removes eight volatile items and indirect taxes, has eased to 2.0%. That is its slowest pace since December 2024, down from 2.9% a year earlier. He also noted that the roughly 93% of the CPI basket that is not energy is now running slightly below the 2% target. In his view, further hikes would rest on assumptions rather than evidence.
BMO’s Benjamin Reitzes landed between the camps. He said nothing in the report demands a hike, but the Bank has focused on headline inflation, and 3.1% is still far from 2%. He estimated that gasoline prices are on track to drop nearly 10% in November, which alone would cut about 0.4 percentage points from annual inflation. Base effects could partly reverse that in December unless pump prices keep falling.
Why KPMG, Scotiabank and Macquarie Still See Tightening Ahead
Not everyone is convinced the Bank will step back. Daniel Hyun, senior economist at KPMG Canada, acknowledged that three weak jobs reports and sluggish activity strengthen the case for patience. Even so, KPMG is keeping its call for another 25-basis-point hike in December.
Hyun pointed to energy prices, especially diesel, which remain high despite coming off their peaks. He also cited the other pressures behind the Bank’s view that inflation will stay near 3% into 2027: higher industrial input costs, Canadian counter-tariffs and past currency weakness. The trade dispute behind those tariffs is still unresolved, with U.S. trade officials saying recently that they have been in contact with Canadian counterparts on a Canada-U.S. trade deal. Hyun added that back-to-back hikes have historically been part of the Bank’s approach.
Scotiabank’s Derek Holt called the data “probably good enough to hike in December,” pending further information. He argued that the Bank is forward-looking, expects inflation to overshoot its target for much of its forecast horizon, and is unlikely to be swayed by a single month of data. He also said smoothed core measures still point to building underlying pressure.
David Doyle, head of economics at Macquarie Group, said monthly core trends remain firm and base effects will likely push annual measures higher in coming months. Macquarie expects another 100 basis points of hikes by the end of 2027. Its base case for the next quarter-point move is January, though December remains possible.
Servus Credit Union’s Inflation Momentum Index
Servus offered another way to gauge the risk. Its new Inflation Momentum Index, which combines how fast prices are rising with how widely, rose to 0% from -2%. St-Arnaud said the reading shows a slight broadening of price pressure but nothing close to a strong acceleration.

His conclusion matched much of the street. Inflation is still mostly a gasoline story, and underlying measures remain inside the target band. That lowers, though does not remove, the chance of a December increase.
What a December Pause or Hike Would Mean for Canadians
General context, not financial advice: The Bank’s policy rate shapes what banks charge on variable-rate mortgages, lines of credit and many business loans. Another increase would add to borrowing costs for households and companies, while a pause would give them time to absorb the October move.
For businesses, the decision feeds into financing for inventory, hiring and expansion, particularly for smaller firms that depend on bank credit. Recent small business statistics and what they mean for Canadian companies show how sensitive that segment is to credit conditions. Savers face the reverse: higher rates generally lift returns on deposits and short-term fixed-income products. Individual circumstances vary, and readers should consult a qualified adviser before changing borrowing or investment plans.
Gravelle’s Wednesday Remarks Before the Dec. 9 Decision
The next signal comes on Wednesday, November 18, when Deputy Governor Toni Gravelle is scheduled to speak. TD said it will be listening for how he describes current inflation pressures and how confident the Bank is that inflation will rise on a sustained basis, given the recent drop in oil and gasoline prices. KPMG said an upcoming speech by the governor could also change its view.
BMO noted that several major data releases are still due before December 9. Until then, markets are split evenly, and so, it seems, are the economists.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was Canada’s inflation rate in October 2026?
Annual CPI inflation was 3.1%, unchanged from September and slightly below the 3.2% economists expected.
What is the Bank of Canada’s current policy rate?
It is 2.50%, after a 25-basis-point increase on October 28, the Bank’s first hike since 2023.
When is the next Bank of Canada rate decision?
The Bank’s next policy announcement is on December 9, followed by a meeting on January 27, 2027.
Are markets expecting another Bank of Canada rate hike?
Swaps pricing shows roughly even odds for December and a quarter-point hike fully priced by the January 27, 2027, meeting.
The Brand Magazine Newsroom covers Canadian business, markets and policy news for brand builders and entrepreneurs. Newsroom reports are produced from published public sources such as company releases and government and regulator publications, and follow our Editorial Standards.
